Scans of original art are from the Kirby Museum's Original Art Digital Archive.
Scans of pencil art photocopies for the Kirby Museum's Pencil Art Photocopy Archive courtesy of the Kirby Family, with thanks to TwoMorrows Publishing.
Please do not copy any images or content from this site without permission.
Joe Simon mentioned that Kirby's lines were heavier than his so I credited Kirby as inker. Also credits Kirby in comics.org. There are other lighter outline lines that may have been first laid down then the same or another inker added blacks. Frank, Krackles, John S. others? What are your thoughts?
All Kirby's for me.
Kirby's style is looser, he had less brush control than Simon's and inked more with instinct. You can tell inking wasn't his cup of tea but still, it's a solid job, quite effective.
Damn, now John S is going to yell at me!
Why I may agree that this page is inked by Jack, I'm not so sure about the credits that say Joe inked the other three pages of this series (Alarming Tales) in this gallery with the exception of perhaps issue 2 page 1, "The Fireballs!"
Issue 2, page 5 and issue 3, page 5 are in question to me.
BTW--issue 3 page 5 says page 3.
No yelling from me on this one. I agree with you that this is Kirby inking from start to finish: all the figures outlined in pen and the blacks laid in with a brush. Jack's technique was simple and quick -- and quite recognizable here, in my opinion.
the inking looks alot like mort meskins style.
Man, I admire your guts… Now, you need to deal with the One Who Lurks in Shadows!
I'm not really all that familiar with Mort Meskin's inking style, so I couldn't say with any authority whether he did or did not ink this page. The face on the big figure in the lower right looks sort of Meskinish, so maybe, maybe not. We'd need to hear from some people more familiar with the S&K inkers in general, and Meskin in particular, before making a definitive judgement.